{PROOF}

Starring:
Gwyneth Paltrow, Anthony Hopkins, Jake Gyllenhaal and Hope Davis

Director:
John Madden

Running Time:
99 mins

"This could change everything"

After the death of her father, Catherine (Paltrow) fears that she may be developing the same mental illness that drove him to madness and took away the last three years of his life. Robert (Hopkins) was however, a world-renowned mathematician and his assistant Hal (Gyllenhaal) is reading through the hundreds of journals he wrote during his illness to see if there is anything there that can advance mathematics again. As he and Catherine become close, Hal discovers something that could be monumental but could this mathematical proof be Robert's final gift to the world?

Director John Madden is together again with his Oscar winning star of 'Shakespeare in Love', Gwyneth Paltrow but can they recapture the magic?

Based on play by David Auburn and adapted by the writer himself, this story of mental illness, dysfunctional families and self-sacrifice gives Gwyneth Paltrow another chance to shine. Reprising the role she played to great success in London's West End, Paltrow throws herself into the part of Catherine, the woman who sacrificed her education and her work to look after her genius father who has succumbed to mental illness. This is a role that is tailor made for her talents and showcases again that she is a fine actress and one that deserved to win her Oscar.

The story itself is an interesting one and one that is primed for drama. Most of us will know friends or even family members that have given up everything to look after a family member or loved one when they have become ill. When you add in the fact that he is a mathematical genius who still believes he one great piece of work left in him, it only adds to the sense of tragedy. The film analyses how this can affect the person caring for them and how a sick relative can influence the way they think and their outlook for the future.

Joining Gwyneth is a small ensemble that brings the key characters of the play to life. One of Hollywood best young actors, Jake Gyllenhaal continues to impress as Hal, Robert's last assistant and student and growing friend to Catherine. This is a role that highlights Gyllenhaal's ability to play anytime of role in any type of movie, from the romantic interest to the leading man. Hope Davis is an actress who has always made an impression on the indie scene and in supporting roles and this is another fine example of her talent. As Claire, Catherine's sister who has distanced herself from the family's problems, she creates another fine character and one that shows she is a superb actress. Anthony Hopkins brings some class to the film in the smaller role, seen mainly in flashback. As Robert, the troubled mathematical genius we see his fall into madness and the veteran actor uses all of his skill to show this with the emotion that the part needed.

'Proof' might seem like one of those movies that are simply made to win a gold statue during the award season but it has a lot more to offer than that. With excellent performances from the cast and a storyline that hits the right emotional cord to appeal to moviegoers that enjoy a good social drama, this is a film that keeps you enthralled throughout. With the mathematics subplot never getting too complicated or taking over from the family drama, this film proves again that both director Madden and Gwyneth Paltrow always make movies worth watching.

PICTURE & SOUND

Presented in Anamorphic Widescreen 1.85:1 with Dolby Digital 5.1, the presentation is good.

BONUS FEATURES

Audio Commentary
Director John Madden provides a good single person commentary for 'Proof'. The talks passionately about working with Gwyneth Paltrow again after 'Shakespeare in Love' and on the West End stage with the play version of 'Proof', complementing the actress on her ability on both stage and screen. The also highlights the rest of the cast, talking about their impact on the ensemble piece. The maths is also discussed and how it is only the backdrop for the movie. This is a good commentary from an accomplished director.

From Stage to Screen: The Making of Proof (9.42 mins)
Director John Madden, producers Alison Owen and Jeff Sharp, Gwyneth Paltrow, Anthony Hopkins, Jake Gyllenhaal and Hope Davis come together to talk about adapting the play onto the silver screen. The group talk about making a different kind of movie and how it differs from the play. They also talk about casting with Gwyneth Paltrow playing the same role on the stage and the silver screen. They also talk about the meaning of the title 'Proof'.

Deleted Scenes
Entitled 'You're not a real number', 'Harold Dobbs exists' and 'Are you having an affair?', these deleted scenes have optional commentary from director John Madden.

Trailers
Previews of 'Casanova', 'The Greatest Game Ever Played' and 'Flightplan'

OVERALL

While there might not be a lot of extras on the disc but the quality of the commentary track makes up for the short featurette. Fans of the film will be very pleased with the commentary and the presentation of the movie.

DVD

Shakespeare in Love


The Usher Home | Hush, Hush... | The Big Story | The Usher Speaks

Stuck @ Home | Coming Soon | Links | Contact the Usher

2006